← Back to blog

CbCR safe harbour or simplified ETR: how to choose in 2027 when both are available

The CbCR safe harbour was designed as a bridge for the first GloBE filing cycles. For groups with December year-ends, it expires after FY2026. The simplified ETR safe harbour is permanent at a 15% threshold. For periods where both are still technically available, the choice is not obvious. Here is a framework for making it.

The FY2027 landscape

Two transitional safe harbours have dominated Pillar Two compliance planning since the GloBE rules took effect. The Country-by-Country Report (CbCR) safe harbour allows groups to use their existing CbCR data as a proxy for the full GloBE computation in jurisdictions that pass any one of three tests. The simplified ETR safe harbour (introduced via September 2026 Administrative Guidance and effective from FY2026) allows groups to apply a simplified ETR calculation using financial accounting data without computing full GloBE income, provided the result is at or above 15%.

For December year-end groups, the CbCR safe harbour expires after FY2026 (fiscal years ending on or before 31 December 2026). The simplified ETR safe harbour has no expiry. For FY2027, most groups will be working exclusively with the simplified ETR safe harbour for jurisdictions where they want to avoid the full GloBE computation. For non-December year-ends whose FY2026 or later periods began after 31 December 2023, the CbCR safe harbour may still be available for some periods. Those groups face an active choice.

Side-by-side comparison

FeatureCbCR safe harbourSimplified ETR safe harbour
Primary data sourceCbCR (financial accounting, three-year CbCR data)Qualified financial statements
ETR threshold17% simplified ETR (or de minimis thresholds met, or routine profits test passes)15% simplified ETR
Covered taxes in numeratorTax accruals per CbCRTax expense per qualified financial statements, adjusted for GloBE-ineligible taxes
Income measureTotal revenue per CbCR (profit-before-tax basis)Profit-before-tax per qualified financial statements
AvailabilityTransitional: fiscal years beginning before 31 Dec 2026, ending on or before 31 Dec 2026 for Dec year-endsPermanent: no expiry date
Election granularityPer jurisdiction, per yearPer jurisdiction, per year
Three-test structureYes: de minimis, simplified ETR, routine profitsNo: single ETR test only
Uplift for growth jurisdictionsRoutine profits test availableNo equivalent

When the CbCR safe harbour is better

The CbCR safe harbour has two structural advantages over the simplified ETR safe harbour in specific circumstances:

The de minimis test. The CbCR safe harbour includes a de minimis test: a jurisdiction with less than €10m in revenue and less than €1m in profit-before-tax passes automatically, regardless of ETR. For small jurisdictions where the ETR is volatile or uncertain (a loss year with deferred taxes, for example), the de minimis test provides certainty that the simplified ETR test cannot. The simplified ETR safe harbour has no equivalent.

The routine profits test. The third CbCR safe harbour test passes a jurisdiction if its GloBE income does not exceed a substance-based routine return: 7.5% of payroll costs plus 5% of net book value of tangible assets. For high-margin jurisdictions where both ETR tests would fail, the routine profits test can still avoid a full GloBE computation. This is particularly relevant for IP-holding jurisdictions during transition periods where the SBIE calculation alone does not resolve the position.

The 17% threshold leaves more headroom. This sounds counterintuitive, since 17% is higher than 15%. But for jurisdictions where the CbCR simplified ETR is comfortably above 17%, the CbCR safe harbour passes on a looser test, and the qualified financial statement adjustments required for the simplified ETR safe harbour (removing GloBE-ineligible taxes from the numerator) may introduce complexity without benefit.

When the simplified ETR safe harbour is better

For most groups and most jurisdictions from FY2027 onwards, the simplified ETR safe harbour will be the right choice. The reasons:

It is permanent. Planning for the simplified ETR safe harbour builds institutional knowledge and data infrastructure that carries forward indefinitely. Investing in the CbCR safe harbour for a final transitional year is a one-off with no future return.

The 15% threshold is easier to clear for high-tax jurisdictions. In jurisdictions with domestic statutory rates well above 15% (the UK at 25%, Germany at 30%, France at 25%), the simplified ETR safe harbour passes on qualified financial statement data without the need to run the CbCR three-test framework. The lower threshold means more jurisdictions pass on the first check.

CbCR data may no longer reflect current group structure. The CbCR safe harbour uses three-year CbCR filing data. For groups that have made acquisitions, disposals or restructurings in recent years, the historic CbCR data may not accurately represent the current constituent entity structure, creating reconciliation work. The simplified ETR safe harbour uses current-year financial statements.

A three-step decision framework for each jurisdiction

For each jurisdiction where you are considering a safe harbour election for a period where both options remain available:

  1. Run the simplified ETR safe harbour test first. If the jurisdiction passes at 15% on qualified financial statement data, elect the simplified ETR safe harbour. It is permanent, and passing here means no further analysis is needed for this jurisdiction in future years.
  2. If the simplified ETR test fails, check the CbCR safe harbour. Run all three CbCR tests (de minimis, 17% simplified ETR, routine profits). If any passes, consider whether electing the CbCR safe harbour is appropriate given data quality and planning horizon. Note that this is only available for periods where the CbCR safe harbour has not yet expired.
  3. If neither safe harbour passes, run the full GloBE computation. Record the jurisdiction in your full-computation list and allocate data collection resources accordingly for future periods.

The key operational point: do not skip step 1 to run the CbCR safe harbour first. The simplified ETR safe harbour pass sets up future-year compliance efficiently; the CbCR pass does not carry forward.

Election timing and the overlap window

Both safe harbours are elected on a per-jurisdiction, per-year basis in the GloBE Information Return. For periods in the overlap window (non-December year-ends whose FY2026 periods began after 31 December 2023), the election for each jurisdiction must be confirmed before the GIR filing deadline. Elections cannot be changed after the GIR is filed except where the relevant jurisdiction's domestic rules allow amendments.

Groups should run both tests in parallel during the data-gathering phase and defer the formal election until the GIR is being compiled, so that the final choice reflects actual numbers rather than projections. The simplified ETR calculation in particular can produce different results from the CbCR simplified ETR calculation for the same jurisdiction, because the data sources and eligible tax adjustments differ.

For a full walkthrough of the simplified ETR safe harbour mechanics, see our article on the simplified ETR safe harbour. For the broader filing checklist once safe harbour decisions are made, see the post-filing season checklist.

Pillar2OS runs both safe harbour tests simultaneously and surfaces the results side by side, so the jurisdiction-by-jurisdiction election decision is data-driven rather than sequential. See the Computation Centre.

Sources