What the SBIE is and why it matters
The Substance Based Income Exclusion (SBIE) is a carve-out from GloBE income based on payroll costs and the carrying value of tangible assets in each jurisdiction. It reflects a core design principle of the GloBE rules: returns attributable to real economic substance, payroll spent on employees and capital deployed in physical assets, should not attract a minimum top-up tax. Only returns in excess of that substance floor are subject to the 15% minimum.
In practice, the SBIE frequently determines whether a jurisdiction produces a top-up tax liability at all. Groups with capital-intensive operations or significant local workforces often find that the carve-out brings their effective GloBE income below the level at which a top-up tax would arise. Getting the calculation right therefore has direct cash impact, and the common errors (using gross rather than net asset values, including ineligible payroll) can result in either over- or under-stated liabilities.
The formula
The SBIE for a jurisdiction is the sum of two components:
- Payroll component: eligible payroll costs × applicable payroll carve-out rate
- Tangible asset component: eligible tangible asset carrying value × applicable tangible asset carve-out rate
Both components are calculated per constituent entity and then aggregated to the jurisdiction level. The resulting SBIE amount is deducted from GloBE income for the jurisdiction before computing the ETR and any top-up tax.
The transitional rate schedule
Both carve-out rates are transitional, stepping down each year from 2024 until they reach their permanent levels in 2033. The schedule is set in Article 5.3 of the GloBE Model Rules:
| Fiscal year | Payroll carve-out rate | Tangible asset carve-out rate |
|---|---|---|
| 2024 | 9.8% | 7.8% |
| 2025 | 9.6% | 7.6% |
| 2026 | 9.4% | 7.4% |
| 2027 | 9.2% | 7.2% |
| 2028 | 9.0% | 7.0% |
| 2029 | 8.2% | 6.6% |
| 2030 | 7.4% | 6.2% |
| 2031 | 6.6% | 5.8% |
| 2032 | 5.8% | 5.4% |
| 2033 onwards | 5.0% | 5.0% |
Both rates step down in broadly even increments through 2028, then accelerate from FY2029. The steepest single-year drop is between FY2028 (9.0%/7.0%) and FY2029 (8.2%/6.6%). Groups should model exposure at future rates, not just the current year.
Eligible payroll costs
Eligible payroll costs are the total payroll costs (salaries, wages, employer social security contributions and other employment costs) of covered employees who perform services for the constituent entity in the jurisdiction where the entity is located.
Key exclusions:
- Payroll capitalised into asset values. Where employee costs are capitalised as part of the cost of a tangible asset (e.g., construction-stage labour), those amounts are excluded from the payroll component but may instead be reflected in the tangible asset component.
- Payroll of employees providing services to other group entities. Where employees of one constituent entity perform services for another entity in the group under an intercompany arrangement, the payroll attributable to those cross-entity services is excluded from the SBIE of the employing entity.
- Payroll of employees located outside the entity's jurisdiction. Employees seconded or relocated to another jurisdiction for more than 60 days in the period are treated as working in the host jurisdiction, not the home entity's jurisdiction.
A common error is including the full payroll of shared-service staff who serve group entities in multiple jurisdictions. Only the portion attributable to services rendered within the jurisdiction qualifies.
Eligible tangible assets
Eligible tangible assets are property, plant and equipment (PP&E) located in the jurisdiction of the constituent entity, measured at their average net book value (carrying value after depreciation) for the period. The GloBE rules do not use gross book value.
Key exclusions:
- Financial assets (cash, receivables, investments, derivatives)
- Intangible assets (intellectual property, goodwill, software, licences, and natural resource rights such as mining licences and oil and gas exploration rights, which are classified as intangibles under IFRS)
- Assets held for sale that are not currently used in the business
- Leased assets held by the lessor. Where the constituent entity is the lessor under an operating lease, the leased asset remains in the tangible asset base. Where the constituent entity is the lessee, the right-of-use asset under IFRS 16 is included in the SBIE base, but only to the extent it relates to PP&E (not intangibles or financial leases).
The most common error is using gross PP&E (before accumulated depreciation) rather than net carrying value. This overstates the carve-out and understates the top-up tax liability.
Step-by-step worked example (FY2026)
Consider a group constituent entity in Ireland for fiscal year 2026:
| Input | Amount |
|---|---|
| Eligible payroll costs | €20,000,000 |
| Eligible tangible assets (net book value) | €60,000,000 |
| GloBE income (before SBIE) | €80,000,000 |
| Covered taxes | €12,000,000 |
Step 1: apply FY2026 rates
- Payroll component: €20m × 9.4% = €1,880,000
- Tangible asset component: €60m × 7.4% = €4,440,000
- Total SBIE: €1,880,000 + €4,440,000 = €6,320,000
Step 2: reduce GloBE income
- GloBE income after SBIE: €80,000,000 - €6,320,000 = €73,680,000
Step 3: compute the ETR
- ETR before SBIE: €12m / €80m = 15.0% (at the threshold, no margin)
- ETR after SBIE: €12m / €73.68m = 16.3% (above threshold, no top-up tax)
Without the SBIE, this jurisdiction would sit exactly at the 15% threshold with no headroom. The SBIE carve-out of €6.32m reduces the GloBE income denominator, pushing the ETR to 16.3% and eliminating any top-up tax liability for the period.
SBIE and the UTPR allocation: shared data, different uses
The SBIE and the UTPR allocation formula both use payroll and tangible asset data, but at different aggregation levels. The SBIE is computed per constituent entity, then summed to jurisdiction level. The UTPR allocation uses the same underlying figures but aggregates payroll and tangible assets across all constituent entities in each UTPR-enacting jurisdiction to determine each jurisdiction's share of the UTPR charge.
In practice this means that the data collection effort for SBIE directly supports UTPR modelling. Groups that have accurate, entity-level payroll and tangible asset data for SBIE purposes can derive UTPR allocation figures from the same dataset with no additional collection. See our article on UTPR in 2026 for the allocation mechanics.
What to watch as rates step down
The transitional rates step down each year through 2032. For groups in capital-intensive jurisdictions where the SBIE currently eliminates a top-up tax liability, the declining rates mean that liability may reappear in future years even if the underlying business does not change. FY2029 and FY2030 are the highest-risk transition years for groups with large tangible asset bases: the tangible asset rate falls from 7.0% (FY2028) to 6.6% (FY2029) and 6.2% (FY2030), continuing a steady step-down from the 7.8% starting point in FY2024.
Groups should model the SBIE trajectory through the full rate schedule as part of their multi-year GloBE planning. The question is not whether the jurisdiction is clean today but whether it remains clean at the FY2029 or FY2030 rates.
See our post-filing season checklist for related data quality steps, particularly item 6 on auditing SBIE asset and payroll figures.
Pillar2OS calculates the SBIE automatically for each constituent entity, applying the correct transitional rates for the fiscal year and flagging jurisdictions where the SBIE margin is narrow enough to generate a liability at future rates. See the Computation Centre.